Managing people adds just 5% to posted pay in non-software engineering

In non-software engineering, a posting that manages people lists a median $125K a year, +5% over individual contributors asked for the same experience ($119K), with data and AI close behind (+6%). In healthcare and nursing the gap is +29%. And the word manager is a poor guide: only 49% of US postings with manager in the title lead a team.

  • 12.4% of US postings manage people
  • +16% manager pay premium, typical function
  • 49% of manager titles lead a team
  • 2.71M US postings, Oct 1 to Nov 4
  • Sources: company career sites
Interactive: hover or tap for the numbers.

What we found

  1. In the typical function, a posting that manages people lists 16% more than individual contributors in the same function asked for the same experience. The extra runs from +5% in non-software engineering to +29% in healthcare and nursing ($99K against $77K).
  2. 12.4% of the 2.71M US postings manage people. Retail and hospitality has the highest share (22%), education and training the lowest (3.9%).
  3. Manager in a title often means managing work, not people. Only 4% of account managers, 5% of case managers, 5% of product managers and 14% of project managers lead a team. In product and design, 36% of postings say manager and 8% manage people.
  4. It works the other way too: 54% of the postings that manage people do not say manager in the title. 3 in 5 of those are supervisors, leads or directors; the rest are chefs, charge nurses, superintendents and others whose duties include a team.
  5. By experience asked, the typical function's manager premium is +11% at 2-5 years, +8% at 5-10 years and +42% at 10+ years.
  6. The AI-read people-manager flag alone would miss most of them: on the last 7 days it caught 25% of the postings whose full text names staff to supervise or direct reports; the rule used here caught 71%.

How we made it

US postings on company career sites first seen Oct 1 to Nov 4, 2026. One posting = one employer + job title + city: 4.02M copies became 2.71M postings, and the same title, city and pay range under several company names counts once. Staffing agencies, job aggregators, test accounts and internships are left out.

Manages people: the posting's duties say it supervises, manages, leads, hires and develops, or reviews the performance of staff, a crew or direct reports (a lead of project or cross-functional teams does not count); or its title leads a team by nature (supervisor, foreman, store, shift, general or branch manager, charge nurse, or the form "Manager, Accounting"); or the AI-read people-manager flag is set and the title or the requirements back it. Director and executive titles with no such sign are left out of the pay comparison and count as not managing in the shares.

Pay: published pay in USD only (no estimates), the midpoint of the range made yearly (hourly x 2,080), kept between $20K and $1M. The premium compares the medians of managers and individual contributors with the same experience asked (0-2, 2-5, 5-10, 10+ years) in the same function: individual contributors are weighted to the managers' experience mix. Only postings that state both pay and experience count (101K managers, 561K individual contributors). A median needs 30 postings.

Check: on 328K postings first seen Oct 29 to Nov 4 we read the full text. Of those whose text names direct reports or staff to supervise, the rule caught 71% and the AI flag 25%; 2.0% of the individual contributors had such a sentence, some of them false hits (a form answering "supervises others: no"). So the shares here are, if anything, low.

Left out of the chart: Other (no clear function), Executive & General Management (a function made of leadership titles). Functions come from the job title and the employer's sector. Posted pay, not pay received; a function mixes jobs (a nurse manager and a nursing aide are both healthcare), so part of a premium is which jobs come with a team.

Data: jobs.mobiusengine.ai | https://treg.to/tools/mobiusengine-jobs

Run your own study

This research uses the same live job postings you can search through Treg: open roles read daily from employers' own career sites.

Related research

Free account

Sign in free to use the charts

Every chart's filters, and free live jobs data for ChatGPT, Claude or your code. No card.

or

By continuing you agree to our Terms of use and Privacy policy.